| Matt Genau | 125 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
| CJ Walz | 133 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
| Jacob Bell | 141 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
| John Riena | 149 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
| Derek Ridgeway | 157 lbs | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Troy Keller | 165 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
| Cameron Page | 174 lbs | Jamestown Community College |
| Sergio Crespo | 184 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
| Hunter Harnish | 197 lbs | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| David Carnie | 285 lbs | Niagara County Community College |
Eastern I District Outstanding Wrestler |
||
| Troy Keller | Niagara County Community College | |
