| Matt Englert | Forward | Monroe Community College |
| Radzhan Lomidze | Forward | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Matt Jackson | Midfield | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Kevin Kabongo | Midfield | Monroe Community College |
| Abdi Mganga | Midfield | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Anthony Paris | Midfield | Monroe Community College |
| Jordan Sullivan | Midfield | Monroe Community College |
| Andrew Heft | Defense | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Matt Murray | Defense | Monroe Community College |
| Kyle Bimek | Goalkeeper | Monroe Community College |
| Jason Marczak | Goalkeeper | Mercyhurst University - North East |
